From the editors:

Monday, September 12
Hard to Believe, but Rodgers Looks Even Better
Gary D’Amato • Milwaukee Journal Sentinel • Sept. 9

Newton Shows Unexpected Poise in First NFL Game
Tom Sorensen • Charlotte Observer • Sept. 11

Bradford’s Injury Causes Angst
Bryan Burwell • St. Louis Post-Dispatch • Sept. 12

Blame Spreads Far Beyond Substitute Quarterback
Mike Chappell • The Indianapolis Star • Sept. 12

Tony Romo Mistakes Shouldn’t Surprise
Jean-Jacques Taylor • ESPNDallas.com • Sept. 12

In the fall of 2005, the Madden NFL franchise unleashed QB Vision Control. It was a dreadful day for those novices like me who didn’t own a PlayStation or Xbox but still wanted to play with friends occasionally. We couldn’t figure out how exactly the video game decided Peyton Manning had the peripheral vision of an alligator while David Carr wore an eye patch.

It was hailed as the moment where Madden figured out how to differentiate quarterbacks, a true landmark for the franchise. This wasn’t adding the truck stick or linebacker spy. QB Vision Control affected every passing play (provided you didn’t turn the function off), often 60-plus plays per game.

The feature has its flaws. Big ones. But Vision Control nails one thing: Quarterbacks impact the game in more tangible ways than any other position. Madden needed to handle quarterbacking properly if it wanted its game to be truly realistic.

The 2011 NFL regular season opened Thursday with a dazzling display of quarterback play. Sunday night’s game featured a meltdown from a signal caller who’s experienced them before. In between, men under center were heroic, horrible and hurt. Here are five pieces on five of those quarterbacks.

P.S.: Donovan McNabb was on the cover of Madden NFL 06. Donovan McNabb, he of 39 passing yards Sunday, was the face of a video game touting its new function called “QB Vision Control.” Makes me feel old.




Adi Joseph is a sports copy editor for USA Today and the curator of Hard-Charging, a Tumblr where he posts 5-10 sports journalism links a day.

Five on One appears every Monday.